Maplestreetpress

Blog about sportsbooks

A row of used baseballs on a sunlit wooden surface
Sports journalism

Who Gets to Bat First in a Baseball Game?

In the realm of baseball, it is a longstanding and established custom that the team visiting the field initiates the game by batting in the initial part of each inning, known as the top half. This sets the stage for the home team, which then follows with their turn in the latter part, referred to as the bottom half. This approach not only honors tradition but also injects an additional layer of strategic complexity right from the outset of the game.

Key Points to Consider:

  • In baseball, it’s standard practice for the team playing away from their home field to bat first;
  • There are instances in baseball where the home team might bat first, specifically if the officials have designated the visiting team as the ‘home’ team for that game;
  • The game commences with the leadoff hitter of the batting team;
  • In a typical scenario, the home team has the final opportunity to bat in a game. The only exception is if they are already leading and decide not to undertake their last batting turn;
  • Despite statistical analysis challenging the notion, the perceived benefit of batting last for the home team continues to influence the game;
  • Baseball regulations clearly dictate that the visiting team must bat in the top half of each inning, leading to the home team batting in the bottom half. Notably, this was not always the case. Prior to a rule change in 1950, teams had the discretion to choose their batting order.

In the early days of the sport, home teams often opted to bat first, leveraging it as a strategic advantage. This preference stemmed from the desire to be the first to use a new ball, which was rarely replaced during a game and was in its prime condition at the beginning of the match. Over time, the strategic thinking of managers evolved, and the preference shifted towards batting last. The prevailing belief among coaches, players, and spectators was that having the final batting opportunity in the last inning provided a tactical edge, potentially enhancing the chances of victory. However, it’s noteworthy that while home teams tend to win more games in major leagues, the margin of victory is typically slim.

When exploring the theme of who bats first in baseball, it’s crucial to consider how batting order decisions can impact a player’s on-base plus slugging percentage (OPS), a key metric for evaluating offensive performance in the game.

What Determines Batting Order in Baseball?

A close-up of a baseball player's arm and leather glove

In baseball, the order of batting is a distinct aspect of the game, where the team not playing on their home field, commonly referred to as the visiting or away team, is traditionally the first to bat. This is part of baseball’s unique system of alternating turns at bat, where each game is divided into a set number of innings based on the players’ age level. Each inning is split into two segments: the top half and the bottom half. The visiting team takes their turn at bat in the top half, whereas the home team bats in the bottom half of the inning.

Benefits of Batting First

While the advantages for a team batting first in baseball might seem limited, they do exist. In a sport where momentum plays a crucial role, the primary benefit for the team batting first is the opportunity to establish an early lead. This is particularly significant for the visiting team, as scoring early runs can exert pressure on the home team, potentially leading to the early withdrawal of their starting pitcher and creating a challenging deficit for the home team to recover from.

Challenges of Batting First

The perceived drawbacks of batting first in baseball are often considered minimal. Apart from the challenge of playing in an unfamiliar environment and potentially facing biased officiating, the disadvantages for the team batting first are not substantial. Theodore Turocy, an economist and game theory expert, aimed to quantify the advantage of batting last while creating a baseball simulation model. His findings were unexpected: he discovered no significant advantage in batting last, demonstrating how scientific inquiry can debunk longstanding misconceptions.

Historical Perspective on Batting Order

  • The convention of the visiting team batting first has not always been a staple in baseball;
  • For about ten years (1876–1886) in the National League, with the exception of 1877, the decision on which team batted first was made by a coin toss;
  • In 1885, the American Association, a former major league, introduced the option for the home team to decide their batting turn, a policy adopted by the National League two years later;
  • During the 1894 season in the National League, the home teams chose to bat first in 40.9% of the games (324 out of 793 games). 

This historical context shows the evolution of the batting order convention in baseball.

When the Home Team Bats First in Baseball

Silhouetted batter in black uniform holding a baseball bat

In the world of baseball, it’s a well-established tradition for the home team to bat last, giving them the advantage of having the final opportunity to score in an inning. However, there are rare circumstances where the home team can actually bat first.

This unusual situation arises when officials designate the away team as the home squad for a particular game. In such cases, the visiting team gets the privilege of batting last in the inning, contrary to the usual practice. This scenario typically occurs during tournaments or schedules where the away team has played fewer games than the home team.

One notable instance of this unique occurrence took place in September 2007 involving the Cleveland Indians, a team based in Ohio. Originally scheduled as an April home game for the Indians, a series of canceled games led to a special agreement and a rule change in 2006. This rule change gave Cleveland the option to bat first in this particular game, even though, for all statistical purposes, the Seattle Mariners were still considered the home team.

So, while it’s a rarity in the world of baseball, there are situations where the home team gets the chance to step up to the plate first, creating an intriguing twist in the game’s dynamics.

FAQ 

How is it decided which baseball team bats first?

The decision of which team bats first in baseball is based on the home field advantage. The team playing on their home field is the home team, while their opponents are the visiting team. In cases where the game occurs at a neutral location, one team is still designated as the home team and the other as the visiting team. According to the Official Rules of Baseball, a game commences when the home team players occupy the field, and the visiting team’s first batter steps into the batter’s box.

Who is the first player to bat in a baseball game?

The first player to bat in a baseball game is known as the leadoff hitter. This position is usually reserved for players known for their high on-base percentages and low strikeout rates. Leadoff hitters are typically skilled in making contact, drawing walks, and stealing bases. However, recent trends have seen managers assign this role to players with varied skill sets, including power hitters like George Springer and Kyle Schwarber, who combine on-base proficiency with significant hitting power.

Is there an advantage to batting first or second in baseball?

In baseball, there is no inherent advantage to batting first or second. The first two batters in the lineup generally share similar skills and roles, focusing on making contact and running effectively. Their primary objective is to reach base patiently, setting the stage for the middle-order batters to drive them in.

Which team gets the last chance to bat in baseball?

In baseball, the home team is afforded the last chance to bat. A game is divided into innings, each split into two halves. The visiting team bats in the top half of each inning, while the home team bats in the bottom half. Therefore, the home team always has the opportunity for the last at-bats in a game, except in situations where they lead in the final inning and choose not to bat.

Why does the home team bat last in baseball?

The home team bats last in baseball due to a rule change in 1950. The revised rules dictate the start of the game: the home team’s players take their defensive positions, the visiting team’s first batter steps into the batter’s box, the umpire calls “Play,” and the game begins. This change mandated that the visiting team bats in the top halves of each inning.

Conclusion

The ongoing discussion regarding whether home teams have an advantage when batting last in baseball persists, despite compelling statistical data disproving this notion. Even in the sport’s early history, managers grappled with the decision of whether their teams should bat first or last. The thrilling “walk-off” hits further perpetuate the misconception that teams batting last inherently possess an edge that enhances their chances of winning.

Snyder Mark